🕯️ This shiur was given for the Hilula of the Ohr HaChaim HaKadosh — 15th of Tammuz 5786 Rabbenu Chaim Ben Attar zatsal · May his merit protect us and all of Am Yisrael · Amen
Pinhas — The Small Yod, the Broken Vav and the Vav Held in Trust
Parashat Pinhas · 5786 · Shiur 2
A Man With Spirit In Him
Why Yehoshua, Not Pinhas · God of the Spirits
A shiur by M. Yéhouda Himi
🕯️ In memory of Rav Ron Chaya zt”lThis shiur is also dedicated to the memory of Rav Ron Chaya zt”l, who devoted his life to spreading Torah, awakening return, and strengthening a true peace — a peace rooted in holiness, responsibility, and truth.May the merit of the tzaddik protect us and all Israel. May his soul be bound in the bond of life. Amen.
🎙️
🎙 Full recorded shiur · M. Yéhouda Himi
Pinhas — Shiur 2 · A Man With Spirit In Him
⬇ Download the recording
A Man With Spirit In Him
M. Yéhouda Himi · Parashat Pinhas · Shiur 2

Pinhas stopped the plague and earned "My covenant of peace." We would expect him to inherit Moshe's leadership — yet Hashem chooses Yehoshua (Joshua). Why?

Moshe learns he will not enter the Land — and feels no worry for himself. His first concern: "Let Hashem appoint a man over the assembly." Who will lead Israel in my place? Total self-effacement.

Pinhas (the Yiftah story): as Kohen Gadol he could have annulled the vow — but stood on his honor. And the daughter fell "between the chairs."

Yehoshua (the Achan story): he knew with certainty who had sinned — yet spoke "my son," gently, gave honor and asked for a confession. Only afterward — firm judgment, no favoritism. This is "a man with spirit in him" (Rashi): one who can walk according to the spirit of each person.

📖 Read the full shiur
1 The Context — Pinhas's Act vs. the Need for a Leader

At the end of Balak, while everyone weeps at the Tent of Meeting and no one knows what to do, Pinhas rises, takes the spear and stops the plague. In a place where there are no men — strive to be a man.

Pinhas... has turned back My wrath... and I did not consume Israel Bamidbar 25:11

By all logic, we would expect Pinhas to succeed Moshe. But when the moment of appointment comes (chapter 27), the Torah surprises us.

2 "And Moshe Spoke" — The Request for a Successor
Ascend this Mount Avarim and see the land... and you shall be gathered to your people Bamidbar 27:12-13

Moshe is not shaken and asks nothing for himself. His first concern is who will lead the people in his place.

The verse says "and Moshe spoke to Hashem" — and "speech" (dibbur) is firm language. Moshe stands resolute: "Let Hashem, God of the spirits of all flesh, appoint a man over the assembly" — appoint my successor, now.
⭐ It speaks for itself: Moshe seeks nothing for himself. "Who shall go out before them and come in before them... that the assembly of Hashem be not as sheep that have no shepherd." His whole being — Am Israel.
3 Why Not Pinhas? — Yiftah and His Daughter

In the Book of Shoftim, Yiftah (Jephthah) vows: "Whatever comes out of my door, I will offer up." And his daughter comes out to greet him.

Right after Pinhas comes Parashat Matot — the annulment of vows. The vow could have been undone! And who was the Kohen Gadol? Pinhas.

But Pinhas said: "Let the one who needs the Rav come to him." And Yiftah said: "I won a great victory — let him come to me." Each stood on his honor — and the daughter fell between the chairs.

Pinhas could have acted like Moshe with Korah's faction — who sent to call Datan and Aviram and tried to appease them. Here a point of rigidity surfaced in Pinhas's character.
4 Why Yehoshua? — Achan and the Herem

After the conquest of Jericho, Achan takes from the herem (the banned spoil). Israel falls at Ai — 36 dead — a great humiliation. (Hashem does not reveal who sinned: He does not speak lashon hara.)

Yehoshua casts lots and reaches Achan. Now he knows for certain that this man caused the disaster — and could crush him. Note the approach:

My son, give honor to Hashem, the God of Israel, and make confession to Him... hide nothing from me Yehoshua 7:19
"My son" — gently, with honor, with "please." And only after Achan confesses does Yehoshua become the firm leader and carry out the judgment — with no favoritism. A leader who can be utterly firm with the enemy and utterly gentle with a single Jew.

And after the confession — he carried the judgment through to the end: Achan and all that was his were stoned and burned in the Valley of Achor, and Hashem's fierce anger turned away from Israel — and Ai was conquered at once. The gentleness did not cancel the justice; it only came first.

5 "A Man With Spirit In Him" — and the Parable of the Flock
Take to yourself Yehoshua son of Nun, a man in whom there is spirit Bamidbar 27:18
What is "a man in whom there is spirit"? Surely every one of us has spirit!
⭐ Rashi: "one who can go according to the spirit of each and every person." Before an enemy — firm; before one who needs gentleness — gentle. Each according to his spirit.
Moshe shepherded Yitro's flock: first he held back the large rams and let the small lambs graze the tender grass; then the middling ones; and only at the end the big ones. He gives each according to its measure — that is "a man with spirit in him," the rooted trait that passed from Moshe to Yehoshua, his disciple.
6 The Ohr HaChaim HaKadosh — God of the Spirits

In honor of the Hilula: the Ohr HaChaim asks — why specifically the title "God of the spirits"? And why "who shall go out... and who shall come in"?

On the surface: does Moshe really fear that Hashem would fail to appoint a fitting successor?!
⭐ The Ohr HaChaim's answer: God forbid that anyone is removing Moshe from his role. Rather Moshe says: "I will go as You say — but first set this right." Until a man is found who can lead Israel at least as I do — I am going nowhere.

And from his words you learn: if such a man is found, Moshe consents to be gathered to his people. Moshe's interest was entirely, 100%, Am Israel. May the merit of the Ohr HaChaim HaKadosh protect us.

🎯 Test Yourself

Five questions. Click on an answer.

1
What did Moshe ask for before his passing?
Moshe sought nothing for himself — only a leader for the people. Total self-effacement: his interest was 100% Am Israel.
2
Why did Yiftah's daughter fall "between the chairs"?
The vow could have been annulled after Parashat Matot. But each man waited for the other to come to him — and the tragedy followed.
3
How did Yehoshua approach Achan?
Even knowing Achan caused the defeat, Yehoshua spoke tenderly first — and only after the confession carried out the firm judgment.
4
What is "a man with spirit in him" according to Rashi?
Like Moshe with the flock — each according to its measure. The true leader meets every person according to his spirit.
5
What do we learn from the Ohr HaChaim's answer?
"I will go as You say — but appoint a worthy successor first." Until then, Moshe is going nowhere. His whole concern was the people.

Result

📅 Seven-Day Programme — Pinhas Shiur 2
Sunday
Read Bamidbar 27:12-23. Watch Moshe ask not for himself, but for a shepherd for Israel.
Monday
Where do I stand on my own honor — like Pinhas and Yiftah — when flexibility is what is needed?
Tuesday
Study the Achan story (Yehoshua 7). Firm with the enemy, gentle "my son" with one who erred.
Wednesday
"A man with spirit in him." Today, speak to each person according to his spirit — firm or gentle as needed.
Thursday
Do one act where you set your ego aside to fix a problem — as Moshe sought out Datan and Aviram.
Friday eve
Before Shabbat, thank Hashem for leaders who serve the people and not themselves.
Shabbat
In honor of the Ohr HaChaim HaKadosh's Hilula (15 Tamuz): study his commentary on Pinhas — "God of the spirits." May his merit protect us.
Four Practical Steps
🏠

Shalom Bayit — The Mouth at Home

My covenant of peace — peace begins at home. Reveal a Shalom Bayit card.

🔢

Gematria — Rav Ménaché

Shalom, Mashiah, Yisamech — secrets of the letters by Rav Ménaché zatsal.

🔢 Gematria Course
📝

Torah Study

Dig deeper into the Baal HaTurim and Rashi on Parashat Pinhas.

📝 Beith Hamidrach
📚

All Parashot

All shiurim of M. Yéhouda Himi — from Bereshit to Devarim and the festivals.

📚 All Parashot
📕

Books

Torah wisdom in thriller format — Éditions Gueoula.

🌙

Dream Interpretation

Did you dream? Check the meaning according to Rav Almoli.

🌙 Dreams
🎬

Videos

Video shiurim on the festivals, the Menorah and the secrets of the Mishkan.

🎬 Videos
💡

Idea Box

An idea, a remark, a suggestion for the site? Share it with us.

💡 Idea Box
🤝

Maasser

Give your Maasser and take part in spreading Torah.

🤝 Maasser
📨 Get the Weekly Shiur
Every week, straight to your inbox. No spam. One-click unsubscribe.
🕯️ Dedicate This Shiur
Special Hilula dedication available — in honor of the Ohr HaChaim HaKadosh (3 Tammuz).
🧱 Wall of Dedications →
Guardians of the Rift

Guardians of the Rift

A spiritual thriller · David Goldberg

Forty-nine gates open — the fiftieth hides in a single moment. An ancient secret resurfaces, and one man stands between the rift and the world. Drawn from Talmud and Kabbalah.

📖 Read the free excerpt · Book $9.90