The Secret of Barrenness and the Intrinsic Value of Woman
Parashat Vayetze · The Secret of Barrenness and the Intrinsic Value of Woman · Sefer Bereshit · 5786
Rachel asks for children, Yaakov's enigmatic answer, the distinction between Ishah and Chavah, the secret of the Matriarchs' barrenness, and the divine origin of Israel
The Secret of Barrenness and the Intrinsic Value of Woman
A shiur by Mr. Yehuda Himi — Parashat Vayetzei, Part 3
🎙️
🎙 Listen to the shiur
The Secret of Barrenness and the Intrinsic Value of Woman
⬇ Download the recording
Rachel asks for children, Yaakov's enigmatic answer, the distinction between Ishah and Chavah, the secret of the Matriarchs' barrenness, and the divine origin of Israel
A shiur by Mr. Yehuda Himi — Parashat Vayetzei, Part 3 · The Secret of Barrenness and the Intrinsic Value of Woman · Sefer Bereshit · 5785

Leah too was barren ("He opened her womb"): both of Yaakov's wives were, and "hated" only means "less loved."

To Rachel's plea "Give me children or I die," Yaakov answers harshly, and Hashem rebukes him: his sons will one day stand before Yosef.

Woman is first "Ishah" (person, intrinsic worth) and only after the sin "Chavah" (giver of life): her value does not depend on motherhood.

The Patriarchs' barrenness was intentional: to draw out their prayers, and so that Israel would begin from a blank page.

Israel's lineage traces neither to Terach nor Lavan but to the Holy One Himself: the world was created "for Israel, called Reshit."

📖 Full Text
1 Introduction and Dedication

With G-d's help, we continue our study of Parashat Vayetzei. This study is dedicated to the elevation of the soul of Miriam Ikher Feinberg and of all the departed of the people of Israel.

After Yaakov was received by Lavan the Aramean and married Leah and then Rachel, the Torah tells us a moving scene between Yaakov and Rachel that reveals deep secrets about the nature of woman and the role of Israel.

2 Leah and Rachel: Two Barren Wives
« And Yaakov also came to Rachel, and he loved Rachel more than Leah. He served another seven years. Hashem saw that Leah was hated (senuah), and He opened her womb. And Rachel was barren. »Bereshit 29:30-31
A question from the text The verse says « וַיִּפְתַּח אֶת רַחְמָהּ » (He opened her womb). Why did it need to be "opened" if not because it was closed? So Leah too was barren!

We thus understand that both of Yaakov's wives were barren. Only, there is a barren woman for whom Hashem opens the womb, as compensation for being "hated" — that is, less loved.

A clarification One must never say that Yaakov truly hated Leah. Had he hated her, it would have been forbidden to cohabit with her, and the children would be called "children of the hated one." What then of Reuven? Impossible. "Senuah" here means "less loved" — second place in Yaakov's love.
3 Rachel's Desperate Request

Leah gave birth to Reuven, Shimon, Levi, and Yehuda. Then comes this dramatic verse.

« Rachel saw that she bore no children to Yaakov, and Rachel became jealous of her sister. She said to Yaakov: Give me children (הָבָה לִּי בָנִים), and if not, I am dead (מֵתָה אָנֹכִי)! »Bereshit 30:1

A request that seems extreme: if I have no children, I would rather die.

4 Yaakov's Severe Reaction
« Yaakov's anger flared against Rachel (וַיִּחַר אַף יַעֲקֹב בְּרָחֵל), and he said: Am I in place of G-d, Who has withheld from you the fruit of the womb? (הֲתַחַת אֱלֹקִים אָנֹכִי אֲשֶׁר מָנַע מִמֵּךְ פְּרִי בָטֶן) »Bereshit 30:2

Yaakov stresses: « מִמֵּךְ מָנַע וְלֹא מִמֶּנִּי » — it is from you that He withheld, not from me. "I, Baruch Hashem, already have Reuven, Shimon, Levi, and Yehuda. Why do you come to complain to me?"

The Holy One blessed be He said to him: "Is this how one answers those in distress?!"
5 The Divine Rebuke and Punishment
"Is this how one answers those in distress?! By your life, your sons will one day stand before her son!"

The punishment: all the tribes ("your sons") will stand before "her son" — that is, Yosef — when he reveals his identity and the brothers stand confused and ashamed before him. The whole scene of Parashat Vayigash flows from this harsh answer of Yaakov to Rachel.

6 The Difficulty: How Could Yaakov Speak This Way?

We put the question to Yaakov Avinu himself: how did you come to answer so harshly? To say « הֲתַחַת אֱלֹקִים אָנֹכִי » (Am I in place of G-d) is acceptable.

The real problem But why add "who withheld from you and not from me"? Where is he going with this? What truly was Yaakov's anger against Rachel — the anger of which it is written « וַיִּחַר אַף יַעֲקֹב »?
7 Ishah and Chavah: The First Woman in the Torah

To understand Yaakov's thesis and how he views life, let us look at the first woman in the Torah. Is she called Chavah (Eve)? No — she is not called Chavah at first. The opening verses of the creation of Adam and Eve nowhere mention the name "Chavah."

« Hashem-Elokim built the rib He had taken from the man into a woman (אִשָּׁה, Ishah) and brought her to the man. The man said: This one shall be called woman (Ishah), for from man (Ish) she was taken. »Bereshit 2:21-23

Notice: not "Chavah" but "Ishah" — woman, person — for from man she was taken.

The name Chavah When is the woman first called "Chavah," and by whom? It is not Hashem who gives this name — it is the man.
8 After the Sin: The Name Chavah
« To the woman He said: In pain you shall bear children… And the man called his wife's name Chavah (חַוָּה), for she was the mother of all living (חַי). »Bereshit 3:16-20

He should have called her "Chayah" (living one), since she is the mother of all living. Why "Chavah"?

The word "Chavah" in Aramaic means "serpent" (חִוְיָא) — so that he would always remember that she caused him to stumble in the sin of the serpent.
To be weighed carefully I do not say, G-d forbid, that women are serpents. But this is what the Midrash teaches: Chavah comes from the word for serpent (chivya).
9 The Woman's Double Identity

The woman was first created and called "Ishah" (woman, person). Only after "in pain you shall bear" does she receive the role of "Chavah," giver of life.

« Five things are forbidden on Yom Kippur: eating, drinking, cohabitation, ha-chayah (וְהַחַיָּה), and wearing shoes. »

"Ha-chayah" is not an animal: it means the woman in childbirth, in the language of the Mishnah. Likewise Shemot says the Hebrew women "are Chayot (חַיּוֹת)": like does in the field, they give birth vigorously.

10 The Lesson: Value Not Dependent on Motherhood

The woman was named "Chavah" according to her calling to bring life. But if she does not give birth, is she worth nothing? Wrong! For at the start she was called Ishah: she always has something to give of herself, of her person, quite apart from children.

There are thus two aspects in the woman: the Ishah aspect — the personality, the individual identity — and the Chavah aspect — bringing children.

A young girl before marriage, an older woman past childbearing — are they worth nothing? No! They are "Ishah": to educate, to raise, to transmit the heritage. They have a role in the world.

11 What Angered Yaakov

This is exactly the point that troubled Yaakov Avinu. Rachel had said: « הָבָה לִּי בָנִים וְאִם אַיִן מֵתָה אָנֹכִי » (Give me children, or I am dead).

"You are a woman (Ishah), Rachel our mother! Even without children, you have what you can give to the world!"

"Because you have no fruit of the womb, you should die?! You would have no role in this world?!" — that is what angered him. The woman received a bonus: the power to bring life. But failing to bring it does not, G-d forbid, render her life worthless.

12 The Secret of the Patriarchs' Barrenness

Extending this point: the Matriarchs, and also the Patriarchs, were barren — and not by chance. Sarah, Rivka, Rachel, and even Leah (« וַיִּפְתַּח אֶת רַחְמָהּ »).

First reason: Hashem desires (mitaeh) the prayers of the righteous. He made them barren so that they would pray. But there is a second, deeper reason.

13 The Divine Origin of Israel

Avraham too was barren: he fathered only after the Brit Bein Habetarim. Hashem wanted to form the people of Israel starting from a blank page.

The reasoning Had Avraham and Sarah been able to have children naturally, one would say: "Israel came out of Terach!" Yitzchak would answer that his grandfather is Terach. But by the natural path, nothing would have come from Terach: without Hashem's miracle, there would have been no Yitzchak.

So too with Rachel, Leah, and Rivka — so that Lavan could not say: "I am the grandfather of Yaakov's sons!" His blessing is a zero blessing. Without the intervention of the Holy One blessed be He, there would simply have been no people of Israel.

It emerges that the yichus (lineage) of Israel traces back neither to Terach nor to Lavan, but to the Holy One blessed be He Himself, in person.

14 Bereshit: The World Created for Israel

This is the uniqueness of Israel. Hence we read « בְּרֵאשִׁית בָּרָא אֱלֹקִים » — "In the beginning G-d created" — for Israel, called "Reshit" (beginning): « רֵאשִׁית תְּבוּאָתֹה » (the first of His harvest).

Everything begins with the Head — which is Hashem — and from there the people of Israel unfold. A vast seed, which we need only merit, bringing, with G-d's help, the Mashiach speedily in our days, Amen.

« Rabbi Chanania ben Akashia says: The Holy One blessed be He wished to grant merit to Israel, therefore He multiplied for them Torah and mitzvot, as it is said: Hashem desired, for the sake of His righteousness, to make the Torah great and glorious. »

🎯 Test yourself

Five questions. Click an answer.

1
What does the phrase "He opened her womb" teach about Leah?
If Hashem had to "open" her womb, it was closed: Leah too was barren, like Rachel.
2
According to the shiur, what does "senuah" (hated) mean here regarding Leah?
"Senuah" means "less loved"; had he truly hated her, cohabiting with her would have been forbidden.
3
What punishment does Hashem announce to Yaakov for his harsh answer to Rachel?
The Midrash: "your sons will stand before her son" — fulfilled when the brothers stand ashamed before Yosef in Vayigash.
4
What is the difference between "Ishah" and "Chavah" in this teaching?
The woman was first "Ishah" (personhood, intrinsic value) and received "Chavah" after the sin, per her calling to bring life.
5
Why, per the shiur, did Hashem make the Patriarchs and Matriarchs barren?
Hashem desires the prayers of the righteous, and wanted Israel to trace back to Him alone, not to Terach or Lavan.

Result

📅 7 Days to Internalize Human Worth and Israel's Divine Origin
Sunday
Today, recognize my intrinsic worth apart from what I "produce": I am "Ishah/Ish" first of all.
Monday
Answer someone in distress with compassion, even when I cannot solve their problem — not "harshly" as Yaakov was reproached.
Tuesday
Pray a personal prayer from the depths of the heart (mei-umka de-liba), like Rachel, not mechanically.
Wednesday
Value a person for who they are, not only for what they achieve: call or encourage someone who feels "useless."
Thursday
Study the passage on Ishah and Chavah (Bereshit 2-3) to internalize it and share it with my family.
Friday
Remember that Israel's origin traces back to Hashem Himself, and live the day worthy of this noble lineage.
Shabbat
Add a mitzvah or a set time for Torah, knowing that Hashem "multiplied Torah and mitzvot" to grant us merit.
Four Practical Steps
🏠

Shalom Bayit — The Mouth at Home

My covenant of peace — peace begins at home. Reveal a Shalom Bayit card.

🔢

Gematria — Rav Ménaché

Shalom, Mashiah, Yisamech — secrets of the letters by Rav Ménaché zatsal.

🔢 Gematria Course
📝

Torah Study

Dig deeper into the Baal HaTurim and Rashi on Parashat Devarim.

📝 Beith Hamidrach
📚

All Parashot

All shiurim of M. Yéhouda Himi — from Bereshit to Devarim and the festivals.

📚 All Parashot
📕

Books

Torah wisdom in thriller format — Éditions Gueoula.

🌙

Dream Interpretation

Did you dream? Check the meaning according to Rav Almoli.

🌙 Dreams
🎬

Videos

Video shiurim on the festivals, the Menorah and the secrets of the Mishkan.

🎬 Videos
💡

Idea Box

An idea, a remark, a suggestion for the site? Share it with us.

💡 Idea Box
🤝

Maasser

Give your Maasser and take part in spreading Torah.

🤝 Maasser
📨 Get the Weekly Shiur
Every week, straight to your inbox. No spam. One-click unsubscribe.
🕯️ Dedicate This Shiur
Dedicate this shiur for the days of Bein HaMetzarim — in memory, for healing or for success.
🧱 Wall of Dedications →
Guardians of the Rift

Guardians of the Rift

A spiritual thriller · David Goldberg

Forty-nine gates open — the fiftieth hides in a single moment. An ancient secret resurfaces, and one man stands between the rift and the world. Drawn from Talmud and Kabbalah.

📖 Read the free excerpt · Book $9.90